Her rendition of the 1931 song was praised by Michaeal Slezak of TVLine.com, who said the audition was effortless as she tweaked the classic melody with her dreamy connection to the lyrics.
Gwen Stefani told Amy Vachal her performance was creative and she appeared to be an honest artist. She added that she can facilitate her journey since she already made it. Stefani also said they can “have such a connection.”
Shelton said he was “looking at a superstar” and compared her to Norah Jones and Colbie Caillat. He added that he was so impressed and asked her to pick him.
On the other hand, Adam Levine apologized for being the only judge not to press the button. He said if his team was not full he would have turned around first. Levine also said aside from being sad for not turning around for Vachal, he thought she could win the whole thing.
When Amy Vachal was asked who she will pick as her coach, she picked Williams.